Nearly 4 in 10 Hampton Roads and Williamsburg sellers reduce their price. Local MLS data shows exactly when waiting stops making sense.
By Brad Anderson
Your Friend in Real Estate
All summer I have been hearing agent colleagues say the same thing. “The market is shifting. Sellers are having to reduce their prices. It isn’t really a seller’s market anymore.”
The problem is, I track the numbers, and the numbers still show that we are in a strong seller’s market across Williamsburg and Hampton Roads. So what are my colleagues really trying to say?
Sellers certainly are reducing their prices more often than they were a few years ago. I see it every day. But when real estate people have historically talked about a market “shifting,” we usually meant that the underlying balance of power between buyers and sellers had changed. So I decided to pull the MLS data and see what was really happening.
I looked at more than 4,000 listings across seven different market and property-type combinations in Hampton, Newport News, Greater Williamsburg, and Southern York County (I excluded new construction, since builder inventory can distort the numbers). What I found surprised me.
Depending on the market, somewhere between 37% and 50% of active listings have already had a meaningful price reduction. Call it roughly four out of ten sellers. Yet every one of the markets I studied still has only about 1.8 to 2.7 months of inventory. Historically, a balanced market is generally somewhere around four to six months of supply.
By that measure, we are still firmly in a seller’s market.
So how can four out of ten sellers be reducing their price?
A Seller's Market Is Not a Blank Check
Low inventory gives sellers an advantage. A homeowner who puts a desirable, properly priced house on the market today is competing against relatively few other sellers. That is real leverage.
The mistake is assuming that this gives the seller unlimited pricing power.
The data says buyers are remarkably precise about what they are willing to pay. Across nearly 2,000 closed sales in the areas I studied, the median home sold at essentially 100% of its final asking price. About 80% sold within roughly 98% of the final list price, and about 90% sold within 96%.
Put more simply, almost every home that sells does so within about 5% of its final asking price.
I found something similar when I studied the homes that did require price reductions. For much of the market, the eventual correction tended to fall somewhere around 3% to 5%. At higher price points, the reductions were more often in the 4% to 6% range, which makes sense because luxury homes tend to be more unique and there are fewer good comparable sales.
Put those two findings together and you start to see how tightly calibrated buyers are. Once a home is priced where buyers think it belongs, they tend to pay very close to that number. But if a seller is off by even 4% or 5%, the problem may not be that the seller receives an offer 4% or 5% below asking. The seller may simply receive no offer at all.
That is an important distinction.
Why Buyers May Be Better Calibrated Than Sellers
Think about how today’s serious buyer shops for a home.
Before many buyers ever walk through a front door, they have spent weeks or months looking at Zillow, Realtor.com, Homes.com, and other real estate sites. They know every new listing that has appeared in their price range. They have watched some houses sell immediately, others sit for weeks, and others reduce their prices.
Then they start touring houses.
Now they are comparing photographs and online information with the actual houses. They learn that $625,000 gets them this much house in one neighborhood and something very different ten minutes away. They see the difference between a genuinely renovated kitchen and one with new countertops sitting on 25-year-old cabinets. They see which backyards feel private, which floor plans work, and which improvements they actually value.
After looking at enough homes, buyers develop a surprisingly sophisticated sense of relative value.
Sellers come to the market with a very different set of information.
For starters, sellers generally aren’t out shopping the competition. Interestingly, when I first started in real estate, I frequently took sellers on tours of the homes we believed they would be competing against before we ever listed (I still think that can be an enormously useful exercise, and I am always happy to do it with a potential seller who wants to understand the market before making a decision).
Most sellers, though, haven’t toured ten houses that buyers see as direct alternatives to theirs. They may know what the house across the street sold for or remember what a neighbor told them at a cookout, but that is not the same thing as actually shopping the market.
Sellers are also naturally attached to the choices they have made. At some point, whether five years ago or twenty years ago, the seller looked at the homes available and chose theirs. They thought it was the best house for them. It is pretty natural for some of that preference to remain when it comes time to sell.
Renovations create another problem. If you spent $70,000 remodeling your kitchen, you know exactly what that kitchen cost. You probably remember writing every check. Naturally, you want to believe the improvement added something close to $70,000 to the value of the house.
The next buyer may love the kitchen, but they didn’t choose it. They might have chosen different cabinets, different flooring, or a completely different layout. Part of the value you received from that renovation was getting exactly what you wanted and enjoying it while you lived there. That portion of the value doesn’t necessarily transfer to the next buyer.
Some houses are simply harder to price, too. Pools, acreage, unusual floor plans, waterfront, high-end finishes, and neighborhoods with very little turnover can all make it difficult to find truly comparable sales.
All of this gives sellers a natural tendency to have an optimistic opinion of their home’s value. A strong seller’s market can reinforce that tendency. Sellers hear about low inventory, bidding wars, and homes selling over asking price, and reasonably think they should take advantage of the market. Sometimes that turns into aiming a little higher than buyers are willing to go.
Why Doesn't the Buyer Just Make a Lower Offer?
Suppose a buyer likes a house listed for $525,000 but believes it is really worth $500,000. Why wouldn’t they simply offer $500,000?
Sometimes they do. In my experience, however, there is another important dynamic at work.
Most buyers are trying to buy the best house they can afford, not the cheapest house they can tolerate. Economists would say they are trying to maximize their utility within their budget.
After more than 20 years of working with buyers, I have found that most people ultimately purchase fairly close to the upper end of the price range they are comfortable with. If someone can comfortably afford $500,000, they generally don’t decide to buy a $375,000 house simply because it seems like a value. They use their available budget to get more of the location, condition, space, and features that matter to them.
Now imagine a $500,000 house being offered at $525,000.
The buyer shopping around $525,000 isn’t comparing that house with other $500,000 houses. They are comparing it with the best houses available around $525,000. If those alternatives are nicer, larger, or in better locations, the overpriced house may never make the buyer’s short list.
Now turn the example around.
Imagine a house buyers believe is worth $525,000 being offered at $500,000. Well-calibrated buyers recognize that too. If their budget allows, they are likely to act quickly, and if they sense that other buyers see the same value, they may even bid above asking price to make sure they get it.
That is why small pricing differences can produce dramatically different outcomes. Buyers are not simply asking, “Do I like this house?” They are asking, “Is this the best house I can buy with the money I have available?”
So How Long Does the Market Need to Tell You?
The raw days-on-market data gives us a useful starting point. Homes that go under contract quickly almost never require a price reduction. Once a listing stays on the market longer, the probability that it will eventually require one rises substantially.
I wanted a more useful answer than that, so I looked at the entire population of active, pending, sold, and expired listings and asked a different question. For a home that is still available at its original price on a particular day, what are the odds that it goes under contract during the following week without reducing?
First Week: During the first week, about 14% of those listings went under contract during the following seven days without a reduction.
Day 7-13: During days 7 through 13, the number was about 11%.
Day 14-20: During days 14 through 20, it was still about 11.5%.
So there is nothing particularly magical about day 14.
The statistical picture starts changing more noticeably somewhere around day 20 to 24. From there, the likelihood of selling during the next week begins to decline. By days 28 through 34, that probability had fallen to roughly 8%.
And once a listing gets past about 30 days, it becomes more likely to reduce its price than to go under contract at the existing price.
If days on market were all the information we had, that alone would make a strong case for taking a hard look at the price somewhere around weeks three and four.
But days on market are only part of the information we get. In fact, some of the most useful information about a listing doesn’t exist until the house actually goes on the market. And sometimes that information paints a pretty clear picture much sooner.
You Usually Know More by Day 14 Than the Statistics Do
Once a home is listed, a good listing agent should know how many people have seen it, how quickly the showings came in, what the buyers thought afterward, whether the house made their top two or three, and why they ultimately chose something else. We can also watch the listings we considered our closest competition. Did they go under contract? Did they reduce their price? Did a new listing appear that offers buyers more for the same money?
All of that is information.
Suppose six buyers tour your house during the first weekend and none writes an offer. That tells me something very different from a house that gets only one showing.
In the first example, buyers are finding the house, making appointments, physically seeing it, and deciding not to buy it. In the second example, we haven’t had enough people through the door to know exactly what they think. The lack of showing activity itself becomes part of what we need to diagnose.
As a general rule of thumb, in a normal market I expect somewhere around 10 to 12 serious showings to generate an offer. In a strong seller’s market, I may lower that expectation to something closer to six to eight.
So imagine that your home has been listed for 12 days. Eight buyers have toured it. Nobody has made an offer. Three buyer agents have told us their clients liked the house but it didn’t make the final cut. Two of the homes we thought were our closest competitors have already gone under contract.
I don’t need to wait until day 30 to learn what the market thinks. You usually don’t need 30 days to know your price is wrong. Thirty days is when the statistics finally catch up with what the showing activity has often been telling you for two weeks.
That is why I would use the first two weeks primarily for diagnosis. Watch the rate of showings, listen carefully to the feedback, and watch the competition. If those signals point consistently toward price, take them seriously.
By weeks three and four, if the activity and the statistics are telling us the same thing, it is probably time to act.
A Guideline, Not a Formula
Real estate doesn’t lend itself to rigid formulas.
A million-dollar waterfront property may have a tiny buyer pool. A highly unusual house may need exactly the right person to come along. A home in a neighborhood where almost nothing sells may require more patience because buyers have fewer comparable sales to rely on (Governor’s Land and parts of Kiln Creek come to mind).
The quality of the showing activity matters too. Six showings in two weeks with three buyers saying your house is still among their top choices is different from six showings and six buyers eliminating the house immediately.
Higher-end homes generally take longer and can require larger corrections simply because they are more unique.
Those exceptions call for judgment, but the basic relationship showed up throughout the data. Correctly priced homes tend to move quickly. As days accumulate without a contract, the probability that the original price will eventually need to change rises dramatically.
So, When Should You Reduce Your Price?
For most homes in Williamsburg and Hampton Roads, I think the practical answer is this.
Give the market enough time to respond, but start interpreting that response immediately.
During the first 7 to 14 days, pay close attention to showing volume, showing feedback, buyer interest, and your competition. If buyers are seeing the house and consistently choosing something else, the market may already be giving you the answer.
Statistically, the warning lights get much brighter during weeks three and four. By approximately 30 days at the same price, I would want a compelling reason to keep waiting.
When a correction really is necessary, the MLS data suggests that 3% to 5% is often a meaningful range for much of the market. That does not mean every seller should automatically cut 5%. The right adjustment depends on the house, the competition, and what the showing activity has taught us.
Reducing a $500,000 house by $2,000 to $498,000 just so the listing can advertise a “price improvement” probably isn’t going to change a buyer’s opinion of its value. If we decide the market has rejected the original price, the new price needs to put the house into a genuinely different competitive position.
A meaningful reduction can also put the house in front of an entirely different group of buyers whose searches stop at a particular price point. A home listed at $525,000 may not even appear in the search of a buyer who has capped their search at $500,000.
The Bottom Line
There are still plenty of buyers in our market. Inventory remains low. Properly priced homes continue to sell quickly, often very close to asking price.
A seller’s market gives you an advantage. It doesn’t relieve you of the need to get the price right.
The market will tolerate low inventory. It will not tolerate a bad price for very long.
So beyond the eventual sale price, is there a cost to starting too high and correcting later instead of pricing competitively from the beginning? There is, and it may be bigger than most sellers assume, not just in the price you eventually accept, but in every negotiation that happens after you’re under contract. Closing costs, inspection repairs, seller possession, appraisal gaps, a buyer’s whole posture toward you changes once the urgency is gone. I get into exactly how in “The Hidden Cost of Overpricing Your Home”.
Need Local Guidance on Your Next Home Transaction?
If you’re thinking about selling a home in Williamsburg or Hampton Roads, or you’re simply curious about what your house might be worth, I’d be happy to help you look at the competition before you make any decisions.
We can even go see some of it together (sometimes there is no better way to understand what buyers are seeing than to shop the market the same way they do).
Your Friend in Real Estate,
Brad Anderson
(757) 816-2968
bradandersonrealestate@gmail.com
Brad Anderson is a licensed REALTOR® with eXp Realty, holding an MBA from William & Mary and bringing nearly 20 years of real estate experience to buyers and sellers across Williamsburg, Yorktown, Newport News, and the Virginia Peninsula.
Hi, I’m Brad Anderson!
I’m your local Williamsburg real estate agent and, most importantly, your ‘Friend in Real Estate.’
Beyond just market insights for Williamsburg and Peninsula,
I’m here to guide you through every aspect of your journey. That includes even those heartfelt decisions about what truly matters when you’re moving.
I’ll be right there beside you as we explore our unique market, making sure you feel confident and truly supported.
Recent Posts
Categories
Frequently Asked Questions:
How long should I wait before reducing the price of my home?
For most homes in Williamsburg and Hampton Roads, I would use the first 7 to 14 days to gather information from showing activity, buyer feedback, and competing listings. The statistical evidence begins turning more strongly against the original price around days 20 to 24, and after roughly 30 days an unreduced listing becomes more likely to reduce its price than to go under contract at the existing price.
What are the warning signs that my house is overpriced?
Showing activity is one of the best clues. In a strong seller’s market, I generally expect six to eight legitimate showings to produce an offer. In a more normal market, the number may be closer to 10 to 12. Repeated showings without offers, similar negative feedback from multiple buyers, and competing homes going under contract while yours remains available all deserve attention.
How much should I reduce my price?
The MLS data suggests that 3% to 5% is often a meaningful correction for much of the Williamsburg and Hampton Roads market, with somewhat larger reductions becoming more common at higher price points. That is a guideline, not a formula. The right reduction depends on the home and its direct competition.
Does reducing my price make buyers think something is wrong with the house?
Usually, no. Buyers watch price changes all the time. A reasonable reduction during the first few weeks generally looks like a seller responding to market feedback. What can create more concern is a home that sits for a long time with little activity, especially if buyers begin wondering why everyone else has passed on it.
Why not make a very small price reduction first?
A small reduction may not change how buyers compare the home with its competition. It may also leave the property above common search cutoffs. If the evidence tells us the original price has missed the market, the goal should be to move the home into a genuinely different competitive position rather than simply changing the number.
Does this timeline change for luxury or unusual homes?
Yes, sometimes. Luxury homes, waterfront properties, unique houses, and homes in areas with very little turnover can reasonably require more time because the buyer pool is smaller and good comparable sales are harder to find. That is where showing quality and buyer feedback become especially important.
Related
Discover more from Brad Anderson - Trusted Williamsburg Realtor
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
